Sometimes words just don't mean enough. When Rick Pitino talks of integrity or Tiger Woods attempts to seem human the words fall flatter than an American Idol contestant. Own the Podium is starting to feel this way for me.
When Canada introduced the slogan and program in 2005 I was optimistic. Finally we've realized that in order to compete against other countries we cannot have our athletes helping people decide between types of baseboards at your local Rona. They must be training full time and be funded this way. Here's the problem though. When results do not follow, someone has to be held accountable. As it states on the Own the Podium website the goal for Canadians was to finish in first in the medal count and top three in the gold medal count at the 2010 olympics. Well these are lofty goals they are almost laughable at this stage of the games. Canada currently has 9 medals compared to the United States' 24. The Canadian Olympic Committee still holds strong saying that a dominate second week is around the corner but unless the second week involves importing athletes from another country I don't see it happening. Many can point to the different aspects of the sports (judging in skating, the track in luge, skeleton and bobsled, the hill at Whistler) but I point to something else. Simply put we cannot have it all.
I still remember when I was young watching the Boston Bruins being saluted by their home crowd after losing a memorable deciding game in the NHL playoffs. I thought this was good sportsmanship by the fans and players as they acknowledged a great season. My dad thought otherwise. Or as he said it "This would never happen in Montreal". This has stuck with me and made me realize the inherent problem with Own the Podium. In order to "own" it, we cannot salute those who do not finish in the top 3. Or, if I could change my dad's quote "This would never happen in the USA". Our ugly big brothers to the south do not celebrate athletes who try hard but don't quite get it done. Melissa Hollingsworth would not be cheered by Americans for finishing fifth. Pieere Leuders and Jesse Lumsden would not be providing interviews on NBC with smiles on their faces after finsihing fifth in the bobsled. Quite simply put you cannot value every competitor on your team if you want to own the podium. You must make finishing off the podium so socially disgraceful that athletes cannot fathom not winning a medal. Look at countries that traditionally finish high in medal standings. Russia, United States, China...what do they have in common? An unreal competitive nature where 2nd place is not acceptable. Their are no moral victories or people who get famous off of heartwarming stories. There are winners and losers.
Built into the social fabric of Canada is an innate sense that people have value. Not just successful people, but all people. We are conservative fiscally as a country but very socialistic when it comes to programs. Look at our immigration policy, social security, health care, and education systems. They are grounded in the principle that every human has value, regardless of where they are in life. Compare us to the States where only the strong survive and you end up with a country built on cooperation not competition.
You do not need to look farther than the hockey tournament going on in Vancouver currently for evidence. In a game where half the American squad wouldn't have been invited to our summer training camp we get outplayed, outhustled, and outcoached by a group of competitors that realize losing is not an option. Whether our hockey team wins or loses does not matter in the long run since they will all still be heros in their home communities since they made the NHL.
In a country that is consistently voted one of the best places to live in the world there is really no reason to think we need to change our views on the value of our citizens. We support our athletes, win or lose. We support our citizens, win or lose. And while that is a value that I think makes for a great country to live in and to be raised in, it does not lend itself to owning the podium.
Late
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment